@peterappel23Not yet

28 graded picks, first post Oct 4, 2025, latest Sep 29, 2026. Every pick is graded at the price it was posted and against the closing line.

Units won, flat 1u

−2.69u

27 priced picks

ROI

−10.0%

Flat 1-unit stake, priced picks

Record

12-15-1

Win rate 44.4%

CLV

+0.57%

95% interval −1.56% to +3.04%

Beat the fair close

45.5%

Share of priced picks above the no-vig close

Cumulative units, flat 1u

Now −2.7u, peak +5.3u

Flat 1 unit on every graded pick, in game order. An unpriced pick adds nothing.

By sport

By sport
SportPicksRecordROICLVBeat fair closeStatus
NFL217-13-1−26.7%−0.83%46.7%Not yet
NCAAF65-1-0+60.9%+4.38%50.0%Unranked
MLB10-1-0−100.0%−1.39%0.0%Unranked

By market

By market
MarketPicksRecordROICLVBeat fair closeStatus
Player props134-9-0−31.0%−4.34%14.3%Unranked
Total86-2-0+44.4%+4.91%62.5%Unranked
Spread41-2-1−27.5%+1.60%75.0%Unranked
Moneyline31-2-0−47.6%−0.95%33.3%Unranked

Graded picks

28 graded, newest game first. Each links to the original public post.

@peterappel23: graded picks
Game (ET)SportPickTaken, fair closeResultCLVUnits
Tue Sep 29, 5:00 PM ETReconstructedMLBCHW @ HOUHOU ML −117 (original post, opens in a new tab)−117 to a fair close of −114Loss−1.39%−1.00u
Mon Sep 28, 8:15 PM ETReconstructedNFLPHI @ CHICHI +4.5 (−111) (original post, opens in a new tab)−111 to a fair close of −125Win+5.47%+0.90u
Sun Sep 20, 8:20 PM ETReconstructedNFLIND @ KCT. Thornton over 19.5 rec yds (+134) (original post, opens in a new tab)+134Winn/a+1.34u
Sun Sep 20, 8:20 PM ETReconstructedNFLIND @ KCA. Pierce anytime TD (+350) (original post, opens in a new tab)+350 to a fair close of +345Loss+1.03%−1.00u
Sun Sep 20, 4:25 PM ETReconstructedNFLWSH @ DALJ. Daniels over 200.5 pass yds (original post, opens in a new tab)unpricedLossn/an/a
Sun Sep 20, 4:25 PM ETReconstructedNFLWSH @ DALJ. Daniels over 224.5 pass yds (−114) (original post, opens in a new tab)−114 to a fair close of −106Loss−3.60%−1.00u
Sun Sep 20, 4:25 PM ETReconstructedNFLWSH @ DALT. McLaurin anytime TD (+220) (original post, opens in a new tab)+220 to a fair close of +222Loss−0.53%−1.00u
Sun Sep 20, 4:05 PM ETReconstructedNFLJAX @ DENJAX ML +138 (original post, opens in a new tab)+138 to a fair close of +133Loss+2.04%−1.00u
Sun Sep 20, 1:00 PM ETReconstructedNFLMIN @ CHIC. Loveland anytime TD (+185) (original post, opens in a new tab)+185 to a fair close of +212Loss−8.61%−1.00u
Sun Sep 20, 1:00 PM ETReconstructedNFLPIT @ NEA. Rodgers over 0.5 rush yds (−110) (original post, opens in a new tab)−110 to a fair close of −105Win−2.33%+0.91u
Sun Sep 20, 1:00 PM ETReconstructedNFLMIN @ CHIMIN/CHI Under 48.5 (−111) (original post, opens in a new tab)−111 to a fair close of −134Win+8.77%+0.90u
Sun Sep 20, 1:00 PM ETReconstructedNFLGB @ NYJGB −3 (−117) (original post, opens in a new tab)−117 to a fair close of −101Push−6.82%0.00u
Mon Sep 14, 8:15 PM ETReconstructedNFLDEN @ KCDEN +2 (−105) (original post, opens in a new tab)−105 to a fair close of −106Loss+0.44%−1.00u
Sun Sep 13, 4:25 PM ETReconstructedNFLGB @ MINJ. Jennings over 22.5 rec yds (−110) (original post, opens in a new tab)−110Lossn/a−1.00u
Sun Sep 13, 4:25 PM ETReconstructedNFLGB @ MINJ. Jennings over 2.5 rec (+145) (original post, opens in a new tab)+145 to a fair close of +164Loss−7.34%−1.00u
Sun Sep 13, 1:00 PM ETReconstructedNFLTB @ CINTB/CIN Under 51.5 (−112) (original post, opens in a new tab)−112 to a fair close of −123Loss+4.24%−1.00u
Sun Sep 13, 1:00 PM ETReconstructedNFLNYJ @ TENT. Spears over 5.5 rush att (−250) (original post, opens in a new tab)−250Lossn/a−1.00u
Sun Sep 13, 1:00 PM ETReconstructedNFLNYJ @ TENT. Spears over 17.5 rush yds (−110) (original post, opens in a new tab)−110Lossn/a−1.00u
Sun Sep 13, 1:00 PM ETReconstructedNFLTB @ CINA. Iosivas over 1.5 rec (+108) (original post, opens in a new tab)+108 to a fair close of +129Win−9.00%+1.08u
Sun Sep 13, 1:00 PM ETReconstructedNFLNYJ @ TENG. Smith over 5.5 rush yds (−105) (original post, opens in a new tab)−105Winn/a+0.95u
Sun Sep 13, 1:00 PM ETReconstructedNFLBAL @ INDIND +3.5 (−115) (original post, opens in a new tab)−115 to a fair close of −135Loss+7.32%−1.00u
Wed Sep 9, 8:20 PM ETReconstructedNFLNE @ SEASEA ML −175 (original post, opens in a new tab)−175 to a fair close of −159Win−3.50%+0.57u
Sat Sep 5, 10:00 PM ETReconstructedNCAAFUNLV @ HAWUNLV/HAW Under 57.5 (−108) (original post, opens in a new tab)−108 to a fair close of −128Win+8.15%+0.93u
Sat Sep 5, 7:00 PM ETReconstructedNCAAFMOST @ TA&MMOST/TA&M Over 53.5 (−108) (original post, opens in a new tab)−108 to a fair close of +100Loss−3.70%−1.00u
Sat Sep 5, 3:30 PM ETReconstructedNCAAFBAY @ AUBBAY/AUB Under 61.5 (−110) (original post, opens in a new tab)−110 to a fair close of −137Win+10.43%+0.91u
Fri Sep 4, 8:00 PM ETReconstructedNCAAFUTEP @ OUUTEP/OU Over 50.5 (−110) (original post, opens in a new tab)−110 to a fair close of −105Win−2.33%+0.91u
Sat Aug 29, 10:00 PM ETReconstructedNCAAFMEM @ UNLVMEM/UNLV Under 59.5 (−110) (original post, opens in a new tab)−110 to a fair close of −149Win+14.17%+0.91u
Sat Aug 29, 7:00 PM ETReconstructedNCAAFHAW @ STANHAW/STAN Over 48.5 (+100) (original post, opens in a new tab)+100 to a fair close of +101Win−0.47%+1.00u

All 28 graded picks are reconstructed from public posts; none were tracked live yet. Only bets whose game has started are listed. See the methodology.